Criticism as Dutch domain registry plans move to Amazon cloud

Questions are being asked in parliament about the decision by Dutch domain registration foundation SIDN to transfer the dot nl domain and its “complete ICT services” to Amazon’s cloud services. 

SIDN says the move will make managing the technology easier but some tech entrepreneurs have doubts, and now MPs have asked the government, which supports the idea of keeping .nl on Dutch or European servers, to explain why the move has been sanctioned. 

Tech entrepreneur Bert Hubert told BNR radio he opposes the idea of shifting the domain to cloud operators in the US. “If your servers are on your own continent and under your legal surveillance, then you can also be sure that no one will mess with your data,” he said. 

The added value of keeping .nl domain names under Dutch control also means “we control it ourselves and can innovate with it ourselves… When you outsource, you always lose your knowledge,” he said. 

Simon Besteman, managing director of the Dutch Cloud Community said on social media he was shocked by SIDN’s decision. “We have been inundated with questions from the Dutch internet community and our members… who have questions about the ethical as well as compliance and moral aspects.”

SIDN says that all data will remain on European servers and that users will not notice any difference in practice. It also argues that Amazon has the extremely specialised services it needs, and that these are not available in Europe.  

It was a difficult decision to move the systems to Amazon, SIDN technology chief Loek Bakker said in a reaction to the criticism.

“Although we seek to contribute to the strategic digital autonomy of the Netherlands and Europe in numerous ways, the need to assure the permanent availability of .nl and the protection of our data was decisive in this instance. That is, after all, our primary responsibility as a registry.”

Nevertheless, he said “We will be using generic, open-source technology, so that, as soon as it becomes responsible to migrate the system to a Dutch or European cloud service provider, we can do so relatively easily.”

You can smell the nonsense here very clearly – SIDN was and should be a  highly technical company. Apparently the bean counters have taken over and kicked out all the expertise in the name of… cost cutting? Are they aware that the costs of AWS are often higher than the costs of self maintenance? But the manager gets a nice trip to the US in a private jet or something like it?

And nothing about AWS is open source – they are in fact known for taking open source projects and then forking them and then pricing them through the nose.

MPs from GroenLinks, the PvdA and D66 have now asked the government to explain why the move is being made, Hubert said.

SIDN is a foundation that has the right to exploit the .nl domain name, earning some €21 million a year in the process. More than six million .nl domains have been registered. 

Source: Criticism as Dutch domain registry plans move to Amazon cloud –

Robin Edgar

Organisational Structures | Technology and Science | Military, IT and Lifestyle consultancy | Social, Broadcast & Cross Media | Flying aircraft