Apple’s Not Digging Itself Out of This One: scanning your pictures is dangerous and flawed

Online researchers say they have found flaws in Apple’s new child abuse detection tool that could allow bad actors to target iOS users. However, Apple has denied these claims, arguing that it has intentionally built safeguards against such exploitation.

It’s just the latest bump in the road for the rollout of the company’s new features, which have been roundly criticized by privacy and civil liberties advocates since they were initially announced two weeks ago. Many critics view the updates—which are built to scour iPhones and other iOS products for signs of child sexual abuse material (CSAM)—as a slippery slope towards broader surveillance.

The most recent criticism centers around allegations that Apple’s “NeuralHash” technology—which scans for the bad images—can be exploited and tricked to potentially target users. This started because online researchers dug up and subsequently shared code for NeuralHash as a way to better understand it. One Github user, AsuharietYgvar, claims to have reverse-engineered the scanning tech’s algorithm and published the code to his page. Ygvar wrote in a Reddit post that the algorithm was basically available in iOS 14.3 as obfuscated code and that he had taken the code and rebuilt it in a Python script to assemble a clearer picture of how it worked.

Problematically, within a couple of hours, another researcher said they were able to use the posted code to trick the system into misidentifying an image, creating what is called a “hash collision.”


However, “hash collisions” involve a situation in which two totally different images produce the same “hash” or signature. In the context of Apple’s new tools, this has the potential to create a false-positive, potentially implicating an innocent person for having child porn, critics claim. The false-positive could be accidental or intentionally triggered by a malicious actor.


ost alarmingly, researchers noted that it could be easily co-opted by a government or other powerful entity, which might repurpose its surveillance tech to look for other kinds of content. “Our system could easily be repurposed for surveillance and censorship,” writes Mayer and his research partner, Anunay Kulshrestha, in an op-ed in the Washington Post. “The design wasn’t restricted to a specific category of content; a service could simply swap in any content-matching data base, and the person using that service would be none the wiser.”

The researchers were “so disturbed” by their findings that they subsequently declared the system dangerous, and warned that it shouldn’t be adopted by a company or organization until more research could be done to curtail the potential dangers it presented. However, not long afterward, Apple announced its plans to roll out a nearly identical system to over 1.5 billion devices in an effort to scan for CSAM. The op-ed ultimately notes that Apple is “gambling with security, privacy and free speech worldwide” by implementing a similar system in such a hasty, slapdash way.


pple’s decision to launch such an invasive technology so swiftly and unthinkingly is a major liability for consumers. The fact that Apple says it has built safety nets around this feature is not comforting at all, he added.

“You can always build safety nets underneath a broken system,” said Green, noting that it doesn’t ultimately fix the problem. “I have a lot of issues with this [new system]. I don’t think it’s something that we should be jumping into—this idea that local files on your device will be scanned.” Green further affirmed the idea that Apple had rushed this experimental system into production, comparing it to an untested airplane whose engines are held together via duct tape. “It’s like Apple has decided we’re all going to go on this airplane and we’re going to fly. Don’t worry [they say], the airplane has parachutes,” he said.


Source: Apple’s Not Digging Itself Out of This One

Organisational Structures | Technology and Science | Military, IT and Lifestyle consultancy | Social, Broadcast & Cross Media | Flying aircraft